Best Pizza in Breckenridge, Colorado: Top Pizza Places to Try

The Best Pizza Places in Breckenridge, Colorado

Breckenridge, Colorado is famous for its stunning mountain views, world-class skiing, and charming historic downtown. But this old mining town is also home to some of the best pizza in Breckenridge, CO. Whether you are craving a classic New York-style slice, a hearty deep-dish pie, an artisan sourdough crust, or a gluten free option, the pizza places in Breckenridge have something for everyone.

In this local guide we rank the best pizza in Breckenridge, Colorado, covering dine-in spots, quick slices, takeout, delivery, and gluten free pies. Consider it your go-to guide to pizza places in Breckenridge, CO. Most of the town’s pizzerias sit within a few walkable blocks of Main Street and Ridge Street, so you are never far from a good pie. For a closer look at the downtown pizza district, see our guide to Main Street pizza in Breckenridge. For the full picture, see our complete Breckenridge dining guide, and when you want it to go, our roundup of the best takeout and delivery in Breckenridge.

Best Pizza in Breckenridge at a Glance

Best Pizza in Breckenridge: Where to Go

1. Tin Plate Pizza (Best Overall, Dine-In and Takeout)

Set inside a restored 138-year-old mining cabin at 110 S. Ridge Street, Tin Plate Artisan Pizza is our pick for the best pizza in Breckenridge, Colorado. The dough is a 72-hour cold-fermented sourdough made with heirloom wheat from local Moxie Bread Company, topped with house-made mozzarella and cultured butter, then baked to a blistered, tender crust. Good pizza takes time, and the best pizza takes time and quality ingredients. The rustic room and creative seasonal pies make this a must-visit spot for pizza in Breckenridge, CO, whether you dine in or take it to go.

2. Three Daughters Pizza (Best New York-Style Slice)

Three Daughters Pizza is the Harris family’s New York-style sister shop to Tin Plate, tucked into the same historic 110 S. Ridge Street location. Owners James and Meagan Harris named it for their three daughters, Lila, Annie, and Eloise, and built it around the big 16-inch NY-style pies James grew up on. It is a walk-up, to-go spot serving generous foldable slices and whole pies, so it is the easy answer when you want fast, classic New York pizza in Breckenridge without the wait.

3. Giampietro Pasta & Pizzeria (Best Italian Pizzeria)

A longtime staple of Breckenridge’s Italian food scene at 100 N. Main Street, Giampietro Pasta & Pizzeria serves some of the best New York-style pizza in town alongside a full menu of homemade pasta. Plenty of locals and visitors search for Giampietro Pasta & Pizzeria in Breckenridge by name, and for good reason: the hand-tossed thin-crust pies, big Sicilian slices, and hearty pasta plates have made it a downtown institution for years. It is a go-to for anyone craving authentic Italian food in Breckenridge, with generous portions and a lively, family-friendly room right on North Main Street.

4. Downstairs at Eric’s (Best for Families and Groups)

A family-friendly favorite at 111 S. Main Street, Downstairs at Eric’s pairs a laid-back basement atmosphere with arcade games, plenty of TVs, craft beer, and a big menu of pizza and pub food. It is one of the best pizza places in Breckenridge for kids, groups, and anyone catching a game.

5. Fatty’s Pizzeria (Best for Deep-Dish and Sports)

Housed in one of the oldest buildings in Breckenridge at 106 S. Ridge Street, Fatty’s Pizzeria and Sports Bar has been serving locals and visitors for decades. Its deep-dish pizzas, hearty calzones, and full bar keep guests coming back, and the sports-bar setting makes it a reliable spot to watch a game with a pie.

6. Luigi’s Pizzeria (Best Quick, Casual Slice)

Luigi’s is a casual, wallet-friendly spot at 411 S. Main Street serving fast, fresh pizza. Whether you want a quick slice after a day on the slopes or a full pie to bring back to your lodge, Luigi’s Pizzeria has you covered, with games on the TVs and a relaxed local feel. For more budget-friendly picks around town, see our guide to cheap eats in Breckenridge.

Pizza Takeout and Delivery in Breckenridge, CO

If you are staying in a vacation rental or a lodge like the Marriott’s Mountain Valley Lodge or Valdoro Mountain Lodge, takeout and pizza delivery in Breckenridge make an easy night in. Tin Plate Pizza is set up for fast takeout, Three Daughters keeps things simple with walk-up, to-go slices and pies, and several other pizza places in Breckenridge offer carry-out plus delivery through the usual third-party apps. For the full rundown of who delivers and how to order, see our guide to the best takeout and delivery in Breckenridge.

Gluten-Free Pizza in Breckenridge

If you are searching for gluten free pizza in Breckenridge, several pizza places offer options worth trying:

Because kitchens and menus change with the seasons, it is always worth a quick call ahead if you have a serious allergy. For more options beyond pizza, see our full guide to gluten free restaurants in Breckenridge.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best pizza in Breckenridge, CO?

For the best pizza in Breckenridge, CO, locals point to Tin Plate Pizza for its 72-hour sourdough artisan pies and to its New York-style sister shop, Three Daughters Pizza, for classic foldable slices. Giampietro, Downstairs at Eric’s, Fatty’s, and Luigi’s round out the top pizza places in Breckenridge, Colorado, depending on whether you want Italian, family-friendly, deep-dish, or a fast casual slice.

What are the best pizza places in Breckenridge, Colorado?

Our picks for the best pizza places in Breckenridge, Colorado, are Tin Plate Pizza (artisan sourdough), Three Daughters Pizza (New York-style slices), Giampietro Pasta & Pizzeria (Italian), Downstairs at Eric’s (families and groups), Fatty’s Pizzeria (deep-dish and sports), and Luigi’s Pizzeria (quick casual slices).

Where can I get New York-style pizza in Breckenridge?

Three Daughters Pizza, the Harris family’s sister shop to Tin Plate at 110 S. Ridge Street, serves big 16-inch New York-style pies and by-the-slice service to go. Giampietro Pasta & Pizzeria on North Main Street is another strong choice for New York-style pizza in Breckenridge.

Where is Giampietro Pasta & Pizzeria in Breckenridge?

Giampietro Pasta & Pizzeria is at 100 N. Main Street in downtown Breckenridge, right on North Main. It is a longtime local favorite for New York-style pizza, Sicilian slices, and homemade pasta, and it sits just a block from the Ridge Street pizzerias, so it is easy to fold into a downtown pizza crawl.

Is there deep-dish pizza in Breckenridge?

Yes. Fatty’s Pizzeria at 106 S. Ridge Street is the go-to for deep-dish pizza in Breckenridge, alongside calzones and a full sports bar. If you prefer a thinner artisan pie, Tin Plate Pizza serves its 72-hour sourdough crust a block away on the same street.

Where is the best pizza on Main Street in Breckenridge?

Breckenridge’s pizza places cluster around the downtown core. Giampietro Pasta & Pizzeria sits right on North Main Street, and one block off Main on Ridge Street you will find Tin Plate Pizza, Three Daughters Pizza, and Fatty’s Pizzeria, with Luigi’s a few blocks south on Main. For the full downtown rundown, see our guide to Main Street pizza in Breckenridge.

Which Breckenridge pizza places offer takeout and delivery?

Tin Plate Pizza is set up for fast takeout, and Three Daughters offers walk-up, to-go slices and pies. Many other pizza places in Breckenridge, CO, offer carry-out plus pizza delivery in Breckenridge through third-party apps. See our Breckenridge takeout and delivery guide for who delivers and how to order.

Is there gluten-free pizza in Breckenridge?

Yes. Tin Plate Pizza offers a dedicated gluten free crust baked on a separate oven deck for guests with a serious allergy, plus vegan mozzarella for a gluten free and dairy free pie. Piante Pizzeria is fully plant-based with a gluten free crust option, and Giampietro and Downstairs at Eric’s offer gluten free pizza options as well. If you have a serious allergy, call ahead to confirm current preparation, since menus change seasonally.

How many pizza places are in Breckenridge?

Breckenridge has roughly half a dozen dedicated pizza places plus several restaurants that also serve pizza. Our top picks are Tin Plate Pizza, Three Daughters Pizza, Giampietro Pasta & Pizzeria, Downstairs at Eric’s, Fatty’s Pizzeria, and Luigi’s Pizzeria, most of them within a short walk of downtown Main Street.

Final Thoughts

Breckenridge, CO is a paradise for pizza lovers. Whether you are dining in on an artisan sourdough pie, grabbing a quick New York-style slice, or ordering takeout, you will find delicious options to satisfy your cravings. Next time you are in town, start with the best pizza in Breckenridge at Tin Plate. Good pizza takes time, and we think it is worth the trip.

Ready for your next pizza night? See the Tin Plate menu and come in for dinner.

Related Reading: More Tin Plate Pizza Guides